Chapter 24. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION.

Article 1. General Provisions.

Revisers’ Note.—Section 14, c. 15-0, Code 1923 is omitted because repealed by Acts 1925, c. 43 and §§29-36 of said c. 15-0 are omitted because de clared unconstitutional in Commonwealth of Penna v. State of W. Va., 262 U. S. 553.

§1. Definitions.—Except where a different meaning clearly appears from the context, the words “public utility” when used in this chapter shall mean and include any person or persons, or association of persons, however associated, whether incorporated or not, including municipalities, engaged in any business, whether herein enumerated or not, which is, or shall hereafter be held to be, a public service. Whenever in this chapter the words “commission” or “public service commission” occur, such word or words shall, unless a different intent clearly appears from the context, be taken to mean the public service commission of West Virginia.(1913, c. 9, §3; 1915, c. 8, §3; 1921, c. 150, §3; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §3.)

Revisers’ Note.—The first sentence is a redraft of a part of §3, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The initial clause of the first sentence is new and the last sentence is new. The rest of said §3 is covered in §1, art. 2 of this chapter.

§2. Appointment, Qualification and Disqualification of Commissioners; Removal From Office; Terms of Office; Salaries.—There shall be a public service commission of West Virginia which by that name may sue and be sued. The commission shall consist of three members who shall be appointed by the governor with the advice and consent of the senate. The commisioners shall be citizens and residents of this State and at least one of them shall be a lawyer of not less than ten years’ actual experience at the bar. The commissioners in office when this Code becomes effective shall, unless sooner removed, continue to serve until their respective terms expire and until their successors have been appointed and qualified. A commissioner shall be appointed to take office on the first day of June, nineteen hundred and thirty-one, and on the first day of June of every alternate year thereafter. The term of office shall be six years, except that an appointment to fill a vacancy shall be for the unexpired term only. Each commissioner shall, before entering upon the duties of his office, take and subscribe to the oath provided by section five, article four of the Constitution, which oath shall be filed in the office of the secretary of state. The governor shall annually designate one of the commissioners as chairman, and may remove any commissioner for incompetency, neglect of duty, gross immorality or malfeasance in office.

No person while in the employ of, or holding any official relation to, any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter, or holding any stocks or bonds thereof, or who is pecuniarily interested therein, shall serve as a member of the commission. Nor shall any of such commissioners be a candidate for or hold public office, or be a member of any political committee, while acting as such commissioner; nor shall any commissioner or employee of said commission receive any pass, free transportation or other thing of value, either directly or indirectly, from any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter. In case any of such commissioners shall become a candidate for any public office or shall become a member of any political committee, his office as commissioner shall be ipso facto vacated.

Each commissioner shall receive a salary of six thousand dollars per annum, to be paid in monthly installments. The salaries of the members of the commission shall be payable out of the state fund, in the same manner as the salaries of other officers are paid, and charged to the appropriations which have been and shall hereafter be made from time to time by the legislature for the administration of this chapter.(1913, c. 9, §1, 1915, c. 8, §1; 1921, c. 150, §1; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §1.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a redraft of parts of §1, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The provision that the commissioners shall serve “until their successors all have been appointed and qualified” is new. The other changes are formal. The rest of said §1 is covered in §§3, 5 and 6 of this article. The last sentence was a part of §15, c. 15-0, Code 1923.

§3. Secretary and Other Employees; Compensation; Duties.—The commission shall appoint a secretary and such other employees as may be necessary to carry out the provisions of this chapter, and shall fix their respective salaries or compensations. Such secretary and other employees shall hold office during the pleasure of the commission. It shall be the duty of the secretary to keep a full and true record of all proceedings, acts, orders and judgments of the commission, to issue all necessary process, returns and notices, to keep all books, maps, documents and papers ordered filed by the commission, and all orders made by the commission or approved and confirmed by it and ordered to be filed; and shall be responsible to the commission for the safe custody and preservation of all such documents in his office. He may administer oaths in all parts of the State, so far as the exercise of such power is properly incidental to the performance of his duty or that of the commission.(1913, c. 9, §1; 1915, c. 8, §1; 1921, c. 150, §1; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §1.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a redraft, without substantial change, of a portion of §1, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The provision as to fees is omitted because covered by §4 of this article. The rest of said §1 is covered in §§2, 5 and 6 of this article.

§4. Seal; Certification and Other Fees.—The commission shall adopt a seal which shall be affixed to all papers under such regulations as the commission may prescribe. The commission shall likewise prescribe a schedule of fees to be charged for the certification of all records and papers, and sums to be paid witnesses and other costs necessary and incident to hearings before it and order the same paid by the unsuccessful party. All sums collected by the secretary, except witness fees, shall be paid by him into the state treasury and be credited to the public service commission fund provided for in section six, article three of this chapter. The witness fees shall be paid to the person to whom they are allowed. The sums to be paid into the public service commission fund representing the collections of any month shall be so paid on or before the tenth of the following month.(1913, c. 9, §19; 1921, c. 150, §19; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §19.)

Revisers’ Note.—The first sentence is omitted because it is a repetition of matter covered by the preceding section. The words “state treasury and be credited to the public service commission fund” formerly read “special license fund.” At the end of the first sentence, the following words are omitted, because incorporated in §7, art. 1, c. 57: “certified copies of which shall be admitted as evidence in any court of this State.”

§5. Legal Counsel for Commission.—The attorney general, when required by the commission, shall perform legal services under this chapter: Provided, however, That the governor may appoint counsel for the commission, who shall act as legal adviser to the commission, and who shall perform such other legal services in a representing the people in matters under the jurisdiction of the commission as the governor shall direct. It shall be the duty of such counsel to appear for the people in all cases where they are not represented by counsel, but he shall not have control of cases, either before the commission or on appeal therefrom, where the people are represented by counsel. The compensation of such counsel shall be fixed by the commission and he shall be paid as other employees of the commission.(1913, c. 9, §1; 1915, c. 8, §1; 1921, c. 150, §1; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §1.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section was formerly a part of §1, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The rest of said §1 is covered in §§2, 3 and 6 of this article.

§6. Place and Manner of Hearings; How Many Commissioners Must Act.—The general office of the commission shall be kept at the capitol of the State, and kept open on each working day between the hours of nine o’clock a. m., and five o’clock p. m., and in charge of the secretary or some other competent person. Hearings and the taking of evidence may be had at such times and places and in such manner in each particular case as the commission may designate.

The concurrent judgment of two of the commissioners, when in session as a board, shall be deemed the action of the commission, and a vacancy in the commission shall not affect the right or duty of the remaining commissioners to function as a commission.(1913, c. 9, §1; 1915, c. 8, §1; 1921, c. 150, §1; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §1.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a redraft of parts of §1, c. 15-0, Code 1923. In the last sentence, the words “affect the right or duty” formerly read, “embarrass the right.” The proviso at the end of the section is new. The rest of said §1 is covered in §§2, 3 and 5 of this article.

Legislative Note.—The proviso as to hearings by one commissioner, added by the revisers, is omitted.

§7. Rules of Procedure; Commission Not Bound by Rules of Evidence or Pleadings; Seal.—The commission shall prescribe rules of procedure and for taking evidence in all matters that may come before it, and enter such orders as may be just and lawful. In the investigations, preparations and hearings of cases, the commission shall not be bound by the technical rules of pleading and evidence, but in that respect it may exercise such discretion as will facilitate its efforts to understand and learn all the facts bearing upon the right and justice of the matters before it.

The commission shall have a seal bearing the following inscription: “The Public Service Commission of West Virginia.” The seal shall be affixed to all writs and authentications of copies of records, and to such other instruments as the commission shall direct. All courts shall take judicial notice of said seal.(1913, c. 9, §2; 1915, c. 8, §2; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §2.)

Revisers’ Note.—In the second sentence the word “shall” formerly read “may,” and before the words “technical rules of pleading and evidence,” the word “strict” is omitted. The other changes are formal.

Article 2. Powers and Duties of Public Service Commission.

§1. Jurisdiction of Commission.—The jurisdiction of the commission shall extend to all public utilities in this State, except vehicles operated upon streets and roads, and shall include any utility engaged in any of the followin public services :

Common carriage of passengers or goods, whether by railroad, street railroad, motor or otherwise, by express or otherwise, by land, water or air, whether wholly or partly by land water or air; transportation of oil, gas or water by pipe line; sleeping car or parlor car services; transmission of messages by telephone, telegraph or radio; generation and transmission of electrical energy by hydro-electric or other utilities for service to the public, whether directly or through a distributing utility; supplying water, gas or electricity, by municipalities or others; toll bridges, wharves, ferries; and any othe public service except vehicular service upon streets and roads.(1913, c. 9, §3; 1915, c. 8, §3; 1921, c. 150, §3; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §3.)

Revisers’ Note.—The exception as to vehicles operated upon streets and roads is new. One reason for this exception is that, in general, other agencies have jurisdiction over such public utilities. The following phrase is new: “whether directly or through a distributing utility.” The provisions as to public service by air or by radio are new. The rest of §3, c. 15-0, Code 1923, is covered in §1, art. 1 of this chapter.

§2. General Power of Commission to Regulate Public Utilities.—The commission is hereby given power to investigate all methods and practices of public utilities subject to the provisions of this chapter; to require them to conform to the laws of this State and to all rules, regulations and orders of the commission not contrary to law; and to require copies of all reports, rates, classifications, schedules and time-tables in effect and used by such utility or other person, to be filed with the commission, and all other information, desired by the commission relating to such investigation and requirements. The commission may compel obedience to its lawful orders by mandamus or injunction or other proper proceedings in the name of the State in any circuit court having jurisdiction of the parties or of the subject matter, or the supreme court of appeals direct, and such proceedings shall have priority over all pending cases. The commission may change any intrastate rate, charge or toll which is unjust or unreasonable or any interstate charge with respect to matters of a purely local nature which have not been regulated by or pursuant to act of congress and may prescribe such rate, charge or toll as would be just and reasonable, and change or prohibit any practice, device or method of service in order to prevent undue discrimination or favoritism as between persons, localities or classes of freight: Provided, That the commission shall not reduce any rate, toll or charge within ten years after the completion of the railroad or plant to be used in the public service below a point which would prevent such public utility from making a net earning of eight per cent per annum on the legally recognized rate base. But in no case shall the rate, toll or charge be more than the service is reasonably worth, considering the cost thereof. Every order entered by the commission shall continue in force until the expiration of the time, if any, named by the commission in such order, or until revoked or modified by the commission, unless the same be suspended, modified or revoked by order or decree of a court of or competent jurisdiction.(1913, c. 9, §5; 1915, c. 8, §5; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §5.)

Revisers’ Note.—The following words are new: “or any interstate charge with respect to matters of a purely local nature which have not been regulated by or pursuant to act of Congress.” The reason for this change is that in the absence of federal regulation the states can constitutionally regulate such interstate matters. See Port Richmond Ferry v. Hudson County, 234 U. S. 317, and 27 W. Va. L. Quar. 180. The words “cost of construction and equipment of said railroad or plant” are omitted and the following words inserted, “legally recognized rate base.” Under the ruling decisions “cost” is not the rate base which the Constitution protects. See Huntington v. Public Service Commission, 89 W. Va. 703. Hence, a rate permitting eight per cent on “cost” might be unconstitutional. The other changes are formal.

§3. General Power of Commission With Respect to Rates.—The commission shall have power to enforce, originate, establish, change and promulgate tariffs, rates, joint rates, tolls and schedules for all public utilities except carriers by vehicles over streets and roads, including municipalities supplying gas, electricity or water. And whenever the commission shall, after hearing, find any existing rates, tolls, tariffs, joint rates or schedules unjust, unreasonable, insufficient or unjustly discriminatory or otherwise in violation of any of the provisions of this or chapter, the commission shall by an order fix reasonable rates, joint rates, tariffs, tolls or schedules to be followed in the future in lieu of those found to be unjust, unreasonable, insufficient or unjustly discriminatory or otherwise in violation of any provisions of law, and the said commission, in fixing the rate of any railroad company, may fix a fair, reasonable and just rate to be charged on any branch line there of, independent of the rate charged on the main line of such railroad.(1915, c. 8, §22; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §22.)

Revisers’ Note.—The phrase, “except carriers by vehicles over streets and roads,” is new. See revisers’ note to §1 of this article. The other changes are formal.

§4. Procedure for Changing Rates.—No public utility subject to this chapter shall change, suspend or annul any rate, joint rate, charge, rental or classification except after thirty days’ notice to the commission and the public, which notice shall plainly state the changes proposed to be made in the schedule then in force and the time when the changed rates or charges shall go into effect. But the commission may enter an order suspending the proposed rate and prohibiting such public utility from putting such proposed new rate into effect pending the hearing and final decision of the matter, in which case the proposed new rate shall stand suspended until it is determined by the commission whether or not the same is just or reasonable. The proposed changes shall be shown by printing new schedules, or shall be plainly indicated upon the schedules in force at the time, and kept open to public inspection: Provided, however, That the commission may, in its discretion, and for good cause shown, allow changes upon less time than the notice herein specified, or may modify the requirements of this section in respect to publishing, posting and filing of tariffs, either by particular instructions or by general order.

Whenever there shall be filed with the commission any schedule stating a change in the rates or charges, or joint rates or charges, or stating a new individual or joint rate or charge or joint classification or any new individual or joint regulation or practice affecting any rate or charge, the commission shall have authority, either upon complaint or upon its own initiative without complaint, to enter upon a hearing concerning the propriety of such rate, charge, classification, regulation or practice; and, if the commission so orders, it may proceed without answer or other form of pleading by the interested parties, but upon reasonable notice, and, pending such hearing and the decision thereon the commission upon filing with such schedule and delivering to the public utility affected there by a statement in writing of its reasons for such suspension, may suspend the operation of such schedule and defer the use of such rate, charge, classification, regulation or practice, but not for a longer period than one hundred and twenty days beyond the time when such rate, charge, classification, regulation or practice would otherwise go into effect; and after full hearing, whether completed before or after the rate, charge, classification, regulation, or practice goes into effect, the commission may make such order in reference to such rate, charge, classification, regulation or practice as would be proper in a proceeding initiated after the rate, charge, classification, regulation or practice had become effective : Provided, That if any such hearing cannot be conducted within the period of suspension, as above stated, the commission may in its discretion extend the time of suspension for a further period, not exceeding six months. At any hearing involving a rate sought to be increased or involving the change of any fare, charge, classification, regulation or practice, the burden of proof to show that the increased rate or proposed increased rate, or the proposed change of fare, charge, classification, regulation or practice is just and reasonable shall be upon the public utility making application for such change. When in any case pending before the commission all evidence shall have been taken, and the hearing completed, the commission shall, within three months, render a decision in such case.

Where more than twenty members of the public are affected by a proposed change in rates, it shall be a sufficient notice to the public within the meaning of this section if such notice is published once a week for four consecutive weeks in some newspaper of general circulation in the community where the majority of the resident members of the public affected by such change reside or, in case of nonresidents, have their principal place of business within this State.(1913, c. 9, §9; 1915, c. 8, §9; 1921, c. 150, §9; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §9.)

Revisers’ Note.—The phraseology of §9, c. 15-0 Code 1923, is considerably changed. The word “suspend” near the beginning of the first sentence formerly read “cancel.” The last paragraph is new.

§5. Supervision of Public Utilities Licensed by Municipalities, County Courts or Otherwise; Right to Enter Premises, Inspect and Correct Meters.—The commission shall have general supervision of all public utilities having authority under any charter or franchise of any city, town or municipality, county court, or tribunal in lieu thereof, or otherwise, to lay down and maintain wires, pipes, conduits, ducts or other fixtures in, over or under streets, highways or public places for the purpose of furnishing and distributing gas, or for furnishing and transmitting electricity for light, heat or power, or maintaining underground conduits, or ducts for electrical conductors, or for telegraph or telephone purposes, and for the purpose of furnishing water, either for domestic or power purposes, and shall have general supervision of oil and gas pipe lines.

The commission may ascertain the quantity of water, or the quality and quantity of gas or electricity supplied by such utilities and examine the methods employed, and shall have power to order such improvements as will best promote the public interests.

The commission shall have power, through its members, inspectors, or employees to enter in, upon and to inspect the property, buildings, plants, fixtures, power houses and offices of any such utilities or municipalities, and shall have power to examine the books and affairs to be investigated by it. The commission shall, when and as necessary, appoint inspectors of gas, electric and water meters. And, when such inspectors are required to act, it shall be their duty to inspect, examine, prove and ascertain the accuracy of any gas, electric, or water meters used or intended to be used for measuring or ascertaining the quantity of gas, electricity or water furnished to, by or for the use of any person, firm or corporation, and, when found to be correct, or made correct, the inspector shall stamp or mark each of such meters with some suitable device, which device shall be recorded in the office of the commission. No public utility shall furnish or put in use any gas, electric or water meter which shall not have been inspected, proved and stamped or marked by an inspector of the commission: Provided, That in cases of emergency, gas, electric or water meters may be installed and used before being inspected, but notice thereof shall be immediately given to the public service commission by the public utility installing the same, and such meters shall be inspected, proved and stamped or marked, as soon thereafter as practicable. Every gas, electric and water utility shall provide and keep in and upon its premises suitable and proper apparatus, to be approved and stamped or marked by the commission, for testing and. proving the accuracy of gas, electric and water meters furnished for use by it and by which apparatus every meter may and shall be tested on the written request of the consumer to whom the same shall be furnished, and in his presence if he so desires.

If any person, firm or corporation to or by whom a meter has been furnished shall request the commission in writing to inspect such meter, the commission shall have the same inspected and tested. If the same on being tested shall be found to be two per cent from being correct, or shall be found to be to the prejudice of the user, the inspector shall order the owner of such meter forthwith to remove the same and to place instead thereof a correct meter. The expense of such inspecting and testing shall be borne by the owner if such meter be found to be incorrect by two per cent or more. If the meter, on being so tested, shall be found to be correct, or within two per cent of being correct, the expense of such inspection and testing shall be borne by the user. A uniform charge and rule shall be fixed by the commission for this service: Provided, That nothing in this chapter shall prevent the commission from changing and modifying the method of inspecting meters arid adopting such rules and regulations therefor as to the commission may seem just and proper.(1913, c. 9, §10; 1915, c. 8, §10; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §10.)

Revisers’ Note.—Before the words “of oil and gas pipe lines,” in the first sentence, the following words are inserted: “shall have general supervision.” The provision as to healthfulness and quality of water is omitted, because the public health department has jurisdiction as to such matters. The provision as to witnesses and testimony is transferred to §10 of this article. At the beginning of the third sentence of the third paragraph the words “And, when such inspectors are required to act, it shall be their duty” formerly read “whose duty shall be' when required.” After the word “or” in the second sentence of the last paragraph, the following words are inserted: “shall be found to be.” It is provided in the fourth paragraph that “The expense of such inspecting and testing shall be borne by the owner if such meter be found to be incorrect by two per cent or more.” This is in lieu of the words “and the expense of such inspecting shall be borne by the owner,” in §10, c. 15-0, Code 1923. After the second word “correct” in the next to the last sentence, the words “as above provided” are omitted. Other changes of a formal nature are made.

§6. Power as to Connecting Telephone and Telegraph Services.—Whenever, after hearing, upon notice, the public service commission shall determine that public convenience or necessity requires that conduits, subways, poles or other equipment on, over or under any street or highway belonging to or used by any public utility should be used in part by another public utility for the operation of its property in any locality not reached by the lines or connections of one of such utilities, or a municipality, the public service commission may, by order, fix the just and reasonable terms and conditions of such use, and prescribe the compensation to be paid therefor. And, whenever, after hearing, upon notice, the public service commission shall determine that public convenience and necessity require a physical connection for the establishment of a continuous line of communication between any two or more public utilities regularly engaged in the conveyance of telephone or telegraph messages, for the conveyance of such messages between different localities, which are not reached by the lines or connection of one of such utilities, the public service commission, may, by order, ascertain, determine and fix the just and reasonable terms’ and conditions of such physical connection, including just and reasonable rules and regulations and the just and reasonable charge that shall be made to the public for the use of such continuous line between such localities and the division of the charge between such two or more public utilities, and the apportionment of the cost of making such physical connection between such public utilities, and it shall be the duty of such public utility thereafter to conform to such order of the public service commission. But no order shall be made by the public service commission under this section to apply where such use or physical connection will prevent those owning, operating, managing or controlling any part of such conduits, subways, poles or other equipment, or such proposed continuous lines of communication, from performing their public duties, nor result in serious injury to those owning, operating, managing or controlling any part of such conduits, subways, poles or other equipment, or of the proposed continuous line of communication.

Such use so ordered shall be permitted and such physical connection or connections so ordered shall be made; and the terms, conditions and compensation so prescribed for such use and such physical connections shall be the lawful conditions and compensation for such use and physical connection, and the lawful terms and conditions upon which such use and physical connections shall be had and made. Any such order may be from time to time revised by the commission upon application of any interested party or upon its own motion.(1915, c. 8, §§24, 25; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §§24, 25.)

§7. Unreasonable Regulations, Practices and Services.—Whenever, under the provisions of this chapter, the commission shall find any regulations, measurements, practices, acts or service to be unjust, unreasonable, insufficient or unjustly discriminatory, or otherwise in violation of any provisions of this chapter, or shall find that any service is inadequate, or that any service which is demanded cannot be reasonably obtained, the commission shall determine and declare, and by order fix, reasonable measurements, regulations, acts, practices or service, to be furnished, imposed, observed and followed in the State in lieu of those found to be unjust, unreasonable, insufficient or unjustly discriminatory, inadequate or otherwise in violation of this chapter, and shall make such other order respecting the same as shall be just and reasonable.(1915, c. 8, §23; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §23.)

Revisers’ Note.—In the first sentence, the words “demanded cannot be reasonably obtained” formerly read “can be reasonably demanded cannot be obtained.” The last sentence of §23, c. 15-0, Code 1923, is transferred to §3, art. 4 of this chapter.

§8. System of Accounts Established by Commission.—The commission may establish a system of accounts to be kept by public utilities or classify public utilities and establish a system of accounts for each class, and prescribe the manner in which such accounts shall be kept. It may also in its discretion prescribe the forms of accounts, records and memoranda to be kept by such public utilities, including the accounts, records and memoranda of the movement of traffic as well as the receipt and expenditure of moneys, and any other forms, records and memoranda which in the judgment of the commission may be necessary to carry out any of the provisions of this chapter. In the case of utilities subject to the provisions of the act of congress entitled “An act to regulate commerce,” approved February 4, 1887, and the acts amendatory thereof and supplemental thereto, the system of accounts established by the commission and the form of accounts, records and memoranda prescribed by it shall not be inconsistent with the systems and forms from time to time established for such utilities by the interstate commerce commission. But nothing herein contained shall affect the power of the commission to prescribe forms of accounts, records and memoranda covering information in addition to that required by the interstate commerce commission. The commission may, after hearing had upon its own motion or upon complaint, prescribe by order the accounts in which particular outlays and receipts shall be entered, charged or credited.(1915, c. 8, §26; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §26.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made. The last sentence of §26, c. 15-0, Code 1923, is transferred to §2, art. 4 of this chapter.

§9. Information Concerning Public Utilities May be Required and Published by Commission.—The commission may at any time require persons, firms, companies, associations, corporations or municipalities, subject to the provisions of this chapter, to furnish any information which may be in their possession, respecting rates, tolls, charges or practices in conducting their service, and to furnish the commission at all times for inspection any books or papers or reports and statements, which reports and statements shall be under oath, when so required by the commission, and the form of all reports required under this chapter shall be prescribed by the commission (except as provided in section five, article three of this chapter). The commission shall collect, receive and preserve the same, and shall annually tabulate and publish the same in statistical form, together with the acts and proceedings of the commission.(1913, c. 9, §21; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §21.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

§10. Power to Subpoena Witnesses, Take Testimony and Administer Oaths; Contempt; Self-Crimination.—The commission shall have power, either as a commission or by any of its members, to subpoena witnesses and take testimony, and administer oaths to any witness in any proceeding or examination instituted before it or conducted by it with reference to any matter within its jurisdiction. In all hearings or proceedings before the commission the evidence of witnesses and the production of documentary evidence may be required at any designated place of hearing; and in case of disobedience to a subpoena or other process the commission or any party to the proceedings before the commission may invoke the aid of any circuit court in requiring the evidence and testimony of witnesses and the production of papers, books and documents. And such court, in case of refusal to obey the subpoena issued to any person or to any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter, shall issue an order requiring such public utility or any person to appear before such commission and produce all books and papers, if so ordered, and give evidence touching the matter in question. Any failure to obey such order of the court may be punished by such court as contempt thereof. A claim that any such testimony or evidence may tend to criminate the person giving the same shall not excuse such witness from testifying, but such witness shall not be prosecuted for any offense concerning which he is compelled hereunder to testify.(1913, c. 9, §13; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §13.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made. The first sentence was a part of §10, c. 15-0, Code 1923.

Article 3. Duties and Privileges of Public Utilities Subject to Regulations of Commission.

Revisers’ Note.—After the word “classification” in the second sentence the following words are omitted: “in force at the time this act takes effect.” By omitting the word “steam” before the word “railroad” in the last sentence and in the last phrase of the next to the last sentence, that part of the section is made to include any railroad. This change is made to take care of cases where electricity is supplanting steam as a motive force.

§1. Adequate Facilities; Reasonable Rates; Discontinuing Service.—Every public utility subject to this chapter shall establish and maintain adequate and suitable facilities, safety appliances or other suitable devices, and shall perform such service in respect thereto as shall be reasonable, safe and sufficient for the security and convenience of the public, and the safety and comfort of its employees, and in all respects just and fair, and without any unjust discrimination or preference. All charges, tolls and rates shall be just and reasonable, and no change shall be made in any tariffs, rates, joint rates, tolls, schedules or classifications except as herein provided. Every railroad shall permit switch connections for intrastate business to be made with its tracks at suitable and safe points by other carriers or shippers, upon such terms and conditions as the commission may prescribe, whenever, in the judgment of the commission, the business to be offered by the connecting company or shipper justifies it. Every railroad and other transportation company may be required by the commission to establish and maintain such suitable public service facilities and conveniences as may be reasonable and just, to make reasonable connections with trains on branch lines of such railroads and with all connecting railroad lines; to require any passenger trains to stop at junctions or intersections with other railroads; and may prescribe the number of men required to constitute safe crews for the handling of trains on any railroad in this State or any division of any such railroad. No railroad or other public utility shall discontinue any regular passenger train, or other public service facility, or change any regular passenger train schedule or time-table, without first obtaining authority from the commission so to do, unless the same be done under uniform rules and regulations filed by such railroad or public utility with the public service commission and approved by said commission.(1913, c. 9, §4; 1915, c. 8, §4; 1921, c. 150, §4; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §4.)

Revisers’ Note.—After the word “classification” in the second sentence the following words are omitted: “in force at the time this act takes effect.” By omitting the word “steam” before the word “railroad” in the last sentence and in the last phrase of the next to the last sentence, that part of the section is made to include any railroad. This change is made to take care of cases where electricity is supplanting steam as a motive force.

§2. Discrimination Prohibited.—No public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter shall, directly or indirectly, by any special rate, rebate, drawback or other device or method, charge, demand, collect or receive from any person, firm or corporation, a greater or less compensation, for any service rendered or to be rendered, than it charges, demands, collects, or receives from any other person, firm or corporation for doing a like and contemporaneous service under the same or substantially similar circumstances and conditions.

It shall be unlawful for any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter to make or give any undue or unreasonable preference or advantage to any particular person, company, firm, corporation or locality, or any particular character of traffic or service, in any respect whatsoever, or to subject any particular person, firm, corporation, company or locality, or any particular character of traffic or service, to any undue or unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage in any respect whatsoever.(1913, c. 9, §§6, 7; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §§6, 7.)

Revisers’ Note.—Sections 6 and 7, c. 15-0, Code 1923, are combined in this section.

§3. Connecting Carriers; Common Use of Terminals; Terms and Compensation; Damages; Tap Lines; Plant Facilities.—All common carriers subject to this chapter shall, according to their respective powers, afford all reasonable, proper and equal facilities for the interchange of traffic between their respective lines, and for the receiving, forwarding and delivering of passengers and property to and from their several lines, and those connecting therewith, and shall not discriminate in their rates and charges or methods or manner of service between such connecting lines.

If the commission finds it to be in the public interest and to be practicable, without substantially impairing the ability of a carrier owning or entitled to the enjoyment of terminal facilities to handle its own business, it shall have power to require the use of any such terminal facilities, including main-line track or tracks for a reasonable distance outside of such terminal, of any carrier, by another carrier or other carriers, on such terms and for such compensation as the carriers affected may agree upon, or, in the event of a failure to agree, as the commission may fix as just and reasonable for the use so required, to be ascertained on the principle controlling compensation in condemnation proceedings. Such compensation shall be paid or adequately secured before the enjoyment of the use may be commenced. If under this paragraph the use of such terminal facilities of any carrier is required to be given to another carrier or other carriers, and the carrier whose terminal facilities are required to be so used is not satisfied with the terms fixed for such use, or if the amount of compensation so fixed is not duly and promptly paid, the carrier whose terminal facilities have thus been required to be given to another carrier or other carriers shall be entitled to recover, by suit or action against such other carrier or carriers, proper damages for any injuries sustained by it as the result of compliance with such requirement, or just compensation for such use, or both, as the case may be.

Trunk lines, or principal railroads, shall, in the distribution of cars and the furnishing of facilities, treat industries and shippers, located on and tributary to lateral, industrial or tap lines, as if they were located directly on the track of the trunk lines or principal railroads, and not discriminate between such industries and shippers and those which may be located in direct proximity to their own tracks. And trunk lines or principal railroads shall allow and pay to the lateral, industrial or tap lines, a reasonable and equitable portion of the rate, consistent with the service rendered, giving due consideration to the fact that such lateral, industrial or tap line originates and assembles the freight. But nothing out of the main line rate shall be allowed the shipper or owner for the use of what may be termed “plant facilities.”(1913, c. 9, §8; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §8.)

Revisers’ Note.—The second paragraph is new and is the same as the corresponding provision of the Interstate Commerce Act. This paragraph supersedes the following provision of Code 1923, c. 15-0, §8: “but this shall not be construed as requiring any such common carrier to give the use of its tracks or terminal facilities to another carrier engaged in a like business.”

§4. Passes; Reduced Rates; Exchange of Services and Privileges.—Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to prevent any common carrier from furnishing free transportation to its officers, attorneys, agents and employees, and their families, and like free transportation to the officers, attorneys, agents and employees of other common carriers and their families, mail clerks, expressmen and sleeping car conductors and porters, and like free transportation according to its own regulations to persons devoting their entire time to religious work, and reduced rates to all other persons engaged in religious, charitable and literary pursuits, and for excursions, and for children and students attending schools and colleges, and for commutation tickets; or to prevent telephone, telegraph, sleeping car and express companies from entering into contracts with one another, and with common carriers for the exchange of services, or from exchanging with one another and with common carriers, the privileges of passes or franks for the officers, agents, employees and their families, of such companies and common carriers.(1913, c. 9, §20; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §20; 1929, c. 59.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

Committee’s Note.—This section is amended in conformity with the proviso at the end of Acts 1929, c. 59.

§5. Schedule of Rates to be Filed With Commission.—Every public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter shall file with the commission, and keep open to public inspection, schedules showing all the rates, charges and tolls for service to be rendered by it or by other persons, firms or corporations in connection with it: Provided, however, That the reports and tariffs filed by interstate carriers with the public service commission may be copies of its reports and tariffs filed with the interstate commerce commission; but nothing herein shall preclude the public service commission from requiring interstate carriers to furnish in formation bearing upon any complaint or question pending before said public service commission and with which it has a right to deal.(1913, c. 9, §12; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §12.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

§6. Special License Fee.—There shall be paid by all public utilities subject to the provisions of this chapter a special license fee in addition to those now required by law. Such fees shall be fixed by the auditor upon each of such public utilities according to the value of its property as ascertained by the last assessment, and shall be apportioned among such public utilities upon the basis of such valuation, so as to produce a revenue of eighty thousand dollars per annum, or so much thereof as may be necessary, which shall be paid on or before the twentieth day of January in each year. Such sum of eighty thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary, shall be paid into the state treasury and kept as a special fund designated “Public Service Commission Fund” to be appropriated as provided by law for the purpose of paying the expenses of the commission, and the salaries, compensations, costs and expenses of its employees.(1913, c. 9, §15; 1915, c. 8, §15; 1915, 2nd Ex. Sess., c. 4, §15; 1921, c. 150, §15; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §15.)

Revisers’ Note.—The words “shall be paid into the state treasury and kept as a special fund designated ‘Public Service Commission Fund’ to be appropriated as provided by law” are substituted, for the words “is hereby appropriated and set aside.” The provision as to salaries of commissioners is transferred to §2, art. 1 of this chapter.

Article 4. Violations of Provisions of This Chapter or Orders of Commission.

§1. General Penalties for Violating Provisions of This Chapter.—Every officer, agent, employee, or stockholder of any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter, and every patron, passenger, shipper or consignee, or other person, who shall violate any provision of this chapter, or who procures, aids or abets any violation of any such provision by any such public utility shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined not more than one thousand dollars or be confined in jail not more than one year, or both, in the discretion of the court. When any person is convicted of a violation of any provision of this be chapter, and it is alleged in the indictment on which he is convicted, and is admitted, or by the jury found, that he has been before convicted of the violation of any provisions hereof, committed prior to the violation for which the indictment upon trial was found, then he shall be fined not less than two hundred nor more than two thousand dollars, or be confined in jail not less than thirty days nor more than one year, or both, in the discretion of the court. When any person is convicted of a violation of any provision of this chapter and it is alleged in the indictment upon which he is convicted, and is admitted, or by the jury found, that he has been twice, or oftener, before convicted of a violation of any provisions hereof, committed prior to the violation for which the indictment upon trial was found, then he shall be fined not less than five hundred nor more than five thousand dollars, and shall, in addition thereto, be confined in the county jail not less than three months nor more than one year.(1913, c. 9, §17; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §17.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

§2. Penalty for Falsifying, Destroying or Altering Entries and for Making False Statements.—Any person, officer, agent or employee of any public utility subject to this chapter who shall willfully make any false entries in the accounts, account books, records or memoranda kept by any public utility, or who shall willfully destroy, mutilate, alter or by any other means or device falsify the record of any such accounts, account books, records or memoranda, or who shall willfully neglect or fail to make full, true and correct entries of or in such account, account book, record or memoranda of all the facts and transactions appertaining to such public utility, or who shall falsely make any statement required to be made to the commission, shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined not more than one thousand dollars or be confined in jail not more than one year or both, in the discretion of the court.(1915, c. 8, §26; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §26.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a part of §26, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The words “public utility subject to this chapter” formerly read “such public service corporation.” The other changes are formal. The rest of said §26 is covered in §8, art. 2 of this chapter

§3. Additional Penalties for Violating Certain Orders of Commission.—If any public utility or other person shall fail or refuse to comply with the order of the commission under sections three, seven or nine of article two, such public utility or other person shall, in addition to the other penalties provided for in this chapter, be subject to a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars.(1915, c. 8, §23; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §23.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a part of §23, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The terminology is changed so as to apply to §7 as well as to §§3 and 9. The other changes are formal. The rest of said §23 is covered in §7, art. 2 of this chapter.

§4. Penalty for Violating Orders of Commission for Which no Other Penalty is Provided.—If any person, firm, corporation or officer of a corporation subject to the provisions of this chapter shall fail or refuse to comply with any requirement of the commission hereunder, for which a penalty has not been hereinbefore prescribed, such person, firm, corporation or officer of such corporation shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be subject to a fine of not less than one hundred nor more than five hundred dollars for each offense, and such person or firm, and the officers of such corporation, upon indictment and conviction, may, in the discretion of the court, be confined in jail not to exceed thirty days.(1915, c. 8, §28; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §28.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a redraft of the first sentence of §28, c. 15-0, Code 1923. The rest of said §28 is in §8 of this article.

§5. Violation of Commission’s Orders as Contempt Punishable by Commission.—Any person or public utility who shall violate any of the orders or findings of the commission shall be guilty of contempt, and the commission shall have the same power to punish therefor as is now conferred on the circuit court, with the right of appeal in all cases to the supreme court of appeals.(1915, c. 8, §27; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §27.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

§6. Procedure Before Commission as to Violations.—Any person, firm, association of persons, corporation, municipality or county, complaining of anything done or omitted to be done by any public utility subject to this chapter, in contravention of the provisions thereof, or any duty owing by it under the provisions of this chapter, may present to the commission a petition which shall succinctly state all the facts. Whereupon, if there shall appear to be any reasonable ground to investigate such complaint, a statement of the charges thus made shall be forwarded by the commission to such public utility, which shall be called upon to satisfy such complaint or to answer to the same in writing within a reasonable time to be specified by the commission. If such public utility within the time specified shall make reparation for the injury alleged to have been done, or correct the practice complained of and obey the law and discharge its duties in the premises, then it shall be relieved of liability to the complainant for the particular violation of the law or duty complained of. If such public utility shall not satisfy the complainant within the time specified, it shall be the duty of the commission to investigate the same in such manner and by such means as it shall deem proper.(1913, c. 9, §11; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §11.)

Revisers’ Note.—The words “if there shall appear to be any reasonable ground to investigate such complaint” formerly followed the word “specified” in the last sentence where the word “if” read “or.” Other changes of a formal nature are made.

§7. Damages Recoverable for Violations.—Any person, firm or corporation claiming to be damaged by any violation of this chapter by any public utility subject to the provisions of this chapter, may make complaint to the commission, as provided herein, and bring suit in his own behalf for the recovery of the damages for which such public utility may be liable under this chapter in any circuit court having jurisdiction. In any such action, the court may compel the attendance of any agent, officer, director or employee of such corporation as a witness and require also the production of all books, papers and documents which may be used as evidence, and in the trial thereof such witnesses may be compelled to testify, but any such witness shall not be prosecuted for any offense concerning which he is compelled hereunder to testify.(1913, c. 9, §18; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §18.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

§8. What Constitutes Separate Violation.—Every day during which any person, firm or corporation, or any officer, agent or employee thereof, shall fail to observe and comply with any order or direction of the commission, or to perform any duty enjoined by this chapter, shall constitute a separate and distinct violation of such order or direction of this chapter, as the case may be.(1915, c. 8, §28; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §28.)

Revisers’ Note.—This section is a part of §28, c. 15-0, Code. 1923. The portion of said §28 which provides that the circuit and intermediate courts of Kanawha county shall have concurrent jurisdiction of all offenses and violations of any of the provisions of this chapter is omitted, as §14, art. 3, Const., provides that the venue of crimes and misdemeanors shall be in the county where the alleged offense was committed.

Article 5. Review of Commission’s Action.

§1. Review of Final Orders of Commission.—Any party feeling aggrieved by the entry of a final order by the commission, affecting him or it, may present a petition in writing to the supreme court of appeals, or to a judge thereof in vacation, within thirty days after the entry of such order, praying for the suspension of such final order. The applicant shall deliver a copy of such petition to the secretary of the commission before presenting the same to the court or the judge. The court or judge shall fix a time for the hearing on the application, but such hearing, unless by agreement of the parties, shall not be held sooner than five days after its presentation; and notice of the time and place of such hearing shall be forthwith delivered to the secretary of the commission, so that the commission may be represented at such hearing by one or more of its members or by counsel. If the court or the judge after such hearing be of the opinion that a suspending order should issue, the court or the judge may require bond, upon such conditions and in such penalty, and impose such terms and conditions upon the petitioner, as are just and reasonable. For such hearing the commission shall file with the clerk of said court all papers, documents, evidence and records or certified copies thereof as were before the commission at the hearing or investigation resulting in the entry of the order from which the petitioner appeals. The commission shall file with the court before the day fixed for the final hearing a written statement of its reasons for the entry of such order, and after arguments by counsel the court shall decide the matter in controversy as may seem to be just and right.(1913, c. 9, §16; Code 1923, c. 15-0, §16.)

Revisers’ Note.—Only formal changes are made.

Legislative Note.—The provision giving precedence to a review of the commission’s action is omitted for reasons stated in the revisers’ note to §25, art. 3, c. 11.